I agree that gerrymandering is wrong and also that it is endemic to our current political status.  How do we the people go about protesting/fixing it?

I think part of the solution lies with taking the power to redistrict away from the House of Reps. Perhaps it should reside with the Justice Dept, or maybe the power to determine districts should reside within the state itself. 

Just some initial thoughts.

Views: 638

Replies to This Discussion

I think We might as well start with the definition of "gerrymandering".
gerund or present participle: gerrymandering
  1. manipulate the boundaries of (an electoral constituency) so as to favor one party or class.
    • achieve (a result) by manipulating the boundaries of an electoral constituency.
      "a total freedom to gerrymander the results they want.

Right away I find myself uncomfortable with the concept (in my mind = negative connotations):

"manipulate the boundaries of (an electoral constituency) so as to favor one party or class."

"Manipulation"? "Favoring"? I suppose there are benign forms of "manipulation" (Getting someone to do the right thing). And there are times when it is Good to "favor" something over the other...because the other represents a greater Goodness.

I imagine those that do "gerrymandering", think or profess to have the "higher good" (fairness to others) in their hearts and minds. But I got big doubts here.

Enough of the abstractions for me. Time to get to the point here and that, I think, is playing games with the electorate in order to achieve an advantage...which would, presumably, amount to an election win for their party , or representative(s).

I am more comfortable with set voting districts "carved in stone"...or at least changes enacted only with the approval of the entire voting populous.

But, the Ideal, as I see this right now, is the principle "One Voter, One Vote" No matter where they are located in Our Nation. Ultimately the entire nation is the "voter district" and this is the deciding criteria at the end of the election. When all is said and done and voted for, THAT is the main point of Democratic elections...whether it is for representatives or Will Of The People Policy. Anything less than this is dishonest chicanery. (In my opinion)

If it is necessary to have some sort of designated boundary, for tallying purposes, then the counties within the states should do just fine.

After a little research into 'gerrymandering', I discovered that it is essentially the abuse of redistricting power. House of Rep districts need to be modified to ensure they are equitably representing the people of the United States.  Right now that ratio is 1 Rep for a little over every 700,000 US citizens. After every census, some states lose seats, and others gain. Districts have to be reapportioned to insure equal representation as people move throughout the country.

Turns out 34 states allow the state legislature to modify districts, 7 states set up independent commissions, 3 states have an independent commission, but the state legislature must approve the plan they come up with. The remaining states have a population at or below 700,000 and therefore have the constitutionally mandated 1 rep. I personally think the independent commission is the way to go, but I'm sure assigning people to that commission is a contentious and partisan affair.

Right now I don't think gerrymandering has much of an effect on the independent voter. Republicans and Democrats are primarily focused on divvying up districts to help themselves/hurt each-others chances. They're not focused on us as a threat to control seats. It would be great to see that change in the future, but we need a focused active party before that happens.  I think we have more pressing issues to concern ourselves with and ought to put any gerrymandering debates/complaints on the back burner.



© 2020   Created by Citizens Party   Powered by

Citizens Party Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

About your image
Join our CircleFollow Us On TwitterJoin our CircleVisit Us On FacebookFollow Us Youtube
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger... Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...